Fact Check: Instagram posts – Claim mischaracterizes study’s findings on causes of death for COVID-19 patients

At the COVID-19 pandemic’s onset, ventilators were widely used for patients with the virus who couldn’t breathe on their own. But social media posts are spreading the false claim that ventilators were the primary cause of death for “nearly all” of those patients.

Social media users shared a screenshot of a headline: “Official Report: Ventilators Killed Nearly ALL COVID Patients,” with the subheadline: “Nearly all COVID-19 patients who died in hospital during the early phase of the pandemic were killed as a direct result of being put on a ventilator, a disturbing new report has concluded.” 

The headline also gained traction on Twitter. It was flagged as part of Meta’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.) 

The headline originated on The People’s Voice, a website which has previously spread misinformation. Its May 13 article pointed to a Northwestern University study as evidence that ventilators killed patients. But one of the study’s authors, Dr. Benjamin Singer, told PolitiFact the claim is inaccurate. 

The study reviewed cases of ventilated patients with COVID-19-related pneumonia and other forms of pneumonia and respiratory illness. Singer, an associate professor of medicine at Northwestern University, said the researchers found that patients who had COVID-19-induced pneumonia were much more likely to contract a secondary illness, called ventilator-associated pneumonia. COVID-19 patients contracted the secondary pneumonia at a rate of 57.4% compared with patients with other forms of pneumonia (25%).

Ventilator-associated pneumonia contributed to patients’ deaths, but it wasn’t the primary cause of death — that was COVID-19. 

“The analogy would be if you have a set of patients who are bleeding to death from an automobile accident, right, so a cohort of trauma patients are all taken for surgery to try to stop the bleeding, but a certain number of them die during the surgery to stop the bleeding. You wouldn’t say that the surgery killed the patient, you would say that they died from a car crash,” Singer told PolitiFact.

Ventilators were in high demand at when the pandemic started. Some early data suggested low survival rates for patients who were on them. But, in the second half of 2020, the survival rates of patients on ventilators began to increase. 

Northwestern’s April 27 study was conducted by researchers at the university’s Feinberg School of Medicine who observed cases of ventilator-associated pneumonia and tracked when the pneumonia was unsuccessfully treated. The secondary pneumonia infection can occur in patients who are on a machine for more than 48 hours, the National Library of Medicine wrote. 

Using a computer program called CarpeDiem, the researchers at Northwestern studied the cases of 585 patients with severe pneumonia and respiratory failure, 190 of whom had COVID-19, and those who had contracted the secondary ventilator-associated pneumonia after 48 hours or longer. 

People whose cases of secondary pneumonia were treated successfully had a better chance of survival than those who did not respond to treatment, Singer said. Of 585 patients whose treatments were observed in the study, 243 died — 87 of whom had COVID-19.

“While (ventilator-associated pneumonia) was not associated with mortality overall, mortality was higher in patients with one episode of unsuccessfully treated VAP compared with successfully treated VAP,” the authors wrote.

Overall, the study showed that ventilator-associated pneumonia that didn’t respond to treatment contributed to a higher risk of mortality — but COVID-19 was the primary cause of death. 

Our ruling

Social media posts claimed that “ventilators killed nearly all COVID-19 patients.” 

The claims cited a Northwestern University study as evidence. But the study’s author said the claim is inaccurate. 

Researchers studied ventilator-associated pneumonia, including in patients with COVID-19. They found that while ventilator-associated pneumonia contributed to a higher risk of mortality, it was not the primary cause of death — COVID-19 was. 

We rate the claim that ventilators killed nearly all COVID patients False.